Do you throw this way? Should anyone, in your opinion? Imagine being a coach of young players and taking on the challenging task of introducing pitching form to them: Would you have even considered the notion of showing them this technique (which you know not only exists, but also works with many pitchers) in the early (crucial!) stages of their baseball education?
These are rhetorical questions to which I’m assuming you are saying “No”, “If it works for them”, and “Probably not” respectively.
So, here’s the connection to what I do for a living. Successful writers understand general sentence structure, paragraphing, and building arguments. They know about characterization, the impact of dialogue, the necessity of conflict, and even the usefulness of fragments. Fragments good sometimes. Not always.
However, for the same reason elementary school teachers do not begin the academic year by exploring the nuances of the subjunctive case or the proper uses of the semicolon, I do not think it wise to discuss various advanced writing methods (in all genres) with 100-level students at the college level.
I believe it’s more beneficial to the student to comprehend and apply a “groundwork” notion of writing before exploring more experimental and non-traditional techniques. I never truly wish to quash any student’s aspiration to be creative and funky with their writing, but I also subscribe to the notion that creativity is neither natural or taught. It is, instead, developed. Over time.
So, frankly, I sincerely hope that my students eventually become successful side-armed pitchers with their writing. They will have found their voice, the techniques that work for them as individuals, and are satisfactorily communicating their thoughts to a receptive world who appreciates their contributions.
To get to that point, though, I have to instill that my current students first become strong, confident, over-armed pitchers.